They gave us a republic
blog advertising
is good for you


Labor Strong

Because all wealth comes from labor

Support This Site

I would like to publicly and personally thank regular reader SadOldGuy for his generous contribution that paid the bills to keep this site operating well into 2012. -- BG

Subscribe to
"They Gave Us A Republic"
About Us

This blog is written by a group of liberal patriots who aren't quite as pissed off as they were a couple of years ago, but aren't taking anything for granted, either. We share a fierce dedication to the Constitution - the only words ever put to paper worth dying for, and we'll argue it's finer liberal points with anyone.

We exist to remind y'all that America was founded on four boxes:
  • The Soapbox
  • The Ballot Box
  • The Jury Box
  • The Ammo Box
They should be used in that order. This is our soapbox.

To contact any of the front-page bloggers here, send email to:

Your humble bloghostess is proud to be the recipient of not one, but two much-coveted Golden Monkeyfist awards!

True Golden Monkeyfist - 2007


Best New SoapBlox - 2008

Monkeyfister 2008


Advanced Search

Subscribe to "They Gave Us A Republic"

Newspapers and Columnists

Resource Links

Required Reading

Active Users
Currently 3 user(s) logged on.

View Our Stats

Some basic rules for successful radicals


by: Blue Girl

Wed Oct 05, 2011 at 08:30:00 AM CDT

By @BGinKC

First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win. --Mahatma Gandhi

I cut my political and protest movement teeth on the anti-apartheid divestiture movement of the early eighties.

I was thirteen years old when I became a liberal and a human rights advocate. I know this, because I can pinpoint the day on the calendar that I woke the hell up. It was June 16, 1976. That is the date of the Soweto Riots that sparked the undoing of the apartheid regime in South Africa. When Walter Cronkite told me about the riots, and showed me pictures of children -- my generational peers -- who had been killed by police because they revolted against the white-minority government decree that all school instruction would henceforth be taught in Afrikaans, the language of the white minority -- well, that set my bearing "and that's the way it is."

From that day forward, I made it my business to know what was going on in that country, and to stay up to date on the struggle for freedom of the black majority. A year later, when Biko was killed, I sat shiva and wore black for a month. (It was 1977 and I listened to punk, so I can't be sure anyone noticed that I was wearing black for a reason, but I was.)

When I went to college in 1980, there was an active anti-apartheid organization on campus, and I joined up. That is the movement I cut my political teeth on, and it just so happens that we won. In two decades, Nelson Mandela didn't just walk out of prison on Robin Island, he walked into the presidency and he healed his nation with truth, reconcilliation and forgiveness. His election came 18 years after I first stenciled "FREE MANDELA" on a t-shirt. Change happens slowly. If it happens quickly, it yields chaos and the probability of the change turning out to be for the worse instead of the better approaches 1.

With the success we had in our efforts in mind, and with nothing but high hopes for the ground-shift that is afoot in the form of the Occupy Wall Street movement, I have been doing some thinking about what makes for success when social change is on the line. Call them BG's rules for successful radicals, cribbed heavily from the Civil Rights Movement.


The Occupy Wall Street movement is a real grass-roots movement that is actually rather eerily reminiscent of what they tried to sell the astroturf tea party as back in it's nascent days. Now, the tea party was never a genuine movement, although it did attract some well-meaning and good-intentioned people, most of whom have since dropped out, once they got hip to the fact that the corporatists and theocrats were pulling the strings.

I happen to believe that the very fabric of the republic is in danger of being rendered rags, and I don't want to see that happen, and not just because the nation owes me a pension at 55, either. I have been thinking about what we did in the eighties and in that context I offer some "lessons learned."

  • The traditional media is your enemy. As we have already seen, their first inclination was to ignore. Then Fox started mocking. Then the rest of the press eventually started paying attention - but they did their fair share of mocking, too. Especially Andrew Ross Sorkin of the New York Times. This deliberate and willful effort to ignore the protests and intentional failure to cover dissenting movements is a deliberate effort to cause confusion about what your movement is about within the mainstream, evening-news-and-morning-paper audiences. This is purposefully done in order to piss you off. If they can piss you off, they can make you appear unreasonable, and we all know what happens to unreasonable people...they either get negative attention, or they get rendered invisible.

  • The movement will be infiltrated. Hell, it already has. While the press sends mixed messages or mocks dissident movements, the corporatists who are threatened by the movement are already busy putting operatives in your midst to both disrupt and co-opt.

  • Only after infiltration is accomplished will the media start paying attention. Indeed, that is how you know they have succeeded in planting moles/operatives in your midst. The media won't bother covering you until they know what the answers will be to the questions they ask. we have already seen this with Jesse LaGreca. How long do you think it will take for the M$M to get back to interviewing him on camera again?

  • Politicians will start jumping on your bandwagon -- just as soon as it looks safe to do so. At that point, they will start relating tales and waxing nostalgic about how Wall Street corruption is the very reason they got into politics in the first place, way back in seventh grade when they ran for student council.

  • "Non-Partisan" entities will start writing checks - but their checks will come at a cost. They will "help you organize" and "plan strategy." Once that happens, they control you and the threat you represented is effectively neutralized.

As I keep saying, I want the movement to succeed. I believe that too big to fail is too big to allow. Period. But for the movement to succeed, a few things need to happen.

  • Proclaim the movement to be non-violent and stick to it. Denounce violence. Denounce it with a full-throated roar. The rabblerousers don't help, in fact, the probability is at least .5, and approaches 1,  that they are plants and operatives sent to infiltrate and discredit your movement.

  • Image matters. In fact, image is not half the battle, it is MOST of the battle. It's a myth that Rosa Parks was simply exhausted after a long day at work and too tired to move, I don't care what three different Women's Studies professors insisted when the topic was brought up in class. No, Rosa Parks was active in the local chapter of the NAACP and she was chosen for the action because she was not threatening -- light skinned, delicate features, slight, modest, soft-spoken; the kind of person who could make a person feel guilty for hating her on spec. In other words, she was the perfect face of the movement.

  • Which brings us to: Pick a sympathetic face for your movement, but make god-damn sure the vetting is done beforehand.

  • Decide on one media point person to do interviews and talk to the press. This person needs to be intelligent, quick-witted, attractive, well spoken and affable; someone who is capable of always putting their best face forward. This means looking good and speaking well and staying on message.

  • Resist those "non-partisan" entities and their giant checkbooks. Better you stay independent.

  • Stay focused on the greed, corruption and social inequality that the plutocracy embodies. This is the part that gives me the greatest amount of heartburn. I'm not seeing focus, and until there is focus, the movement won't be taken seriously. Don't get sidetracked by other stuff...Squirrel! In other words, fight one battle at a time. Win one before you try to fight ten at once. I'm sure the Free Mumia kids are already on the scene, but really, what does their cause have to do with this? Nothing. Nothing tangible, anyway. Let me say it one more time, because it's really fucking important: STAY. FOCUSED.

  • Accept that the movement has already been infiltrated and comport yourselves accordingly. Never completely trust anyone who wasn't there before the beginning.

  • Internalize this: "Believe none of what you hear and only half of what you see," and make it your mantra. Our corporate overlords are masters of illusion and they are out to control you and co-opt your movement. They will do whatever they need to in order to achieve that goal, and employ any means necessary to make sure you fail.

  • Take your inspiration from the lowly army ant...enough of them will pick an elephant's carcass clean. Go forth and be those ants.

That's it. That's what a battle-weary veteran of a previous campaign has to offer. I can also tell you that nothing, absolutely nothing, feels better than changing the world. One victory nearly twenty years ago, that took twenty years to fight, is still keeping me going. I never completely give up, because I know what's possible.

I hope, in thirty-five years or so, these protesters have a similar tale of success to tell their kids and grandkids who are righteously pissed about  something, because the republic itself -- and the issue of our future, whether we reclaim "We, the people," or become serfs in a corpocracy -- is riding on their success.

Blue Girl :: Some basic rules for successful radicals
Tags: (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

Response... (0.00 / 0)
Extensive applause. This is a recipe for success...and if we didn't think we were so goddamn smart we'd follow it.

As soon as they REALLY grasp the difference between fact and opinion...They'll shut up.

Thank you, Blue Girl (0.00 / 0)
You make me proud to be a liberal.

One of the best frameworks I've seen (0.00 / 0)
I've been following this closely and this is probably the best description and prescription I've seen yet.  I was around for the protests of the 60s and one of my mortal fears in regard to this one is that the Wall Street parasites will send in a bunch of moles to foment violence and thereby discredit the movement.

As long as we REAL Americans... it's time we coopted that title, by the way... stay cool, we can do this.  

The few with so much will steal the little of so many that the many little people will have nothing left.  Fascism pure and simple.

Small correction: Gandhi never said that. (0.00 / 0)
Minor point, but Mahatma Gandhi actually never said "First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win."

It was Nicholas Klein. I put the correction on the sidebar of my blog, Amygdala, a couple of years ago, because people keep repeating that Gandhi said it, when he didn't.

"First they ignore you. Then they ridicule you. And then they attack you and want to burn you. And then they build monuments to you."
-- Nicholas Klein, May, 1919, to the Third Biennial Convention of the Amalgamated Clothing Workers of America (misattributed to Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi, 1914 & variants)."

Even Wikiquotes has their correction slightly wrong. Which is another reason I decided to note it.

I'm big on attributing credit properly.

Classic Matthew Effect. The more famous you are, the more people give you credit for what other people actually did or said or wrote.

The things I learn from blogging (0.00 / 0)
Thank you. I appreciate the correction. I even googled it first to make sure I had it right (I always want to say "mock" instead of "laugh at" or "ridicule") and every hit on the page attributed it to Gandhi, as I have my entire life.

And I visit you frequently but never noticed the correction in the sidebar. This is where I channel Homer Simpson and say "D'oh!"

When you get raptured, can I have your car?

[ Parent ]
Tactics (0.00 / 0)
Yep, that's the way we did it in the 60s. But beware of liberals who call reactionaries ''radicals.'' They've stolen our language. How can we defeat an enemy who has outposts in our heads?  


Make a New Account



Forget your username or password?

They gave us a republic
blog advertising
is good for you

Join us for libations every Wednesday!
Drinking Liberally - Midtown KC

Vulcan's Forge:

The Midwest's Premiere Sterling Silver Jewelers
Vulcans Forge

Located in the heart of Westport -- The Original Kansas City

Californos Californo's: Elegant dining and a delightful atmosphere, located in the heart of Westport.

Show Me Blue Girl's Favorite Missouri Blogs

M$M efforts (bless their hearts, they try)

Fighting the Good Fight in Kentucky

Spread Us Around

Bookmark and Share

Add to MyYahoo

Add to netvibes

Add to Pageflakes

Subscribe in NewsGator Online

Add to My AOL

They Gave Us a Blogroll
  • A Feather Adrift
  • Achenblog
  • All Spin Zone
  • Amygdala
  • Angry Black Bitch
  • Antemedius
  • Army of Dude
  • Atrios
  • Attackerman
  • Badtux-the Snarky Penguin
  • Balloon Juice (John Cole)
  • Bats Left, Throws Right
  • BeggarsCan BeChoosers
  • Betty Cracker
  • Blind in Texas (Elmo's Playhouse)
  • Blondesense
  • Blue in the Bluegrass
  • BlueGrass Roots
  • Blue Herald
  • Brad Friedman
  • Brilliant at Breakfast
  • 'Burban Mom/Going Green
  • Chef Loves Beer
  • Citizen Carrie
  • Crooks & Liars
  • Distributorcap
  • Docudharma
  • DrugMonkey
  • Driftglass
  • Dr. Sardonicus
  • D. R. Scott's Pulp Culture
  • Earthbound Misfit
  • Eccentricity
  • Everyday Citizen
  • Evil Mommy
  • Feministe
  • Fighting Liberals
  • GI Kate
  • Gone Mild
  • Group News Blog
  • Gun Toting Liberal
  • Hubris Sonic
  • Informed Comment
  • Instaputz
  • Jon Swift
  • Kevin Drum @ Mother Jones
  • Kiko's House
  • Lance Manion
  • Lawyers, Guns & Money
  • Left in Missouri
  • Lower Manhattanite
  • Mad Kane
  • Manifesto Joe
  • Margaret and Helen
  • Media Bloodhound
  • MOMocrats
  • Monkeyfister
  • Mudflats
  • NTodd
  • No More Mr. Nice Blog
  • Outta the cornfield
  • Opit's Linkfest
  • Orcinus
  • Ornery Bastard
  • Out of Iraq Bloggers Caucus
  • Pandagon
  • Pharyngula
  • PhysioProf
  • Political Critic
  • Politicky Bitch
  • PoliTits
  • Rants From the Rookery
  • Rook's Rant
  • Rude Pundit
  • RIPCoco
  • Sam Seder
  • Seeing the Forest
  • Show Me Progress
  • Sic Semper Tyrannis
  • skippy
  • Spook & Muffin's Relaxed Politics
  • SteveAudio
  • Yellow Dog
  • Talking Points Memo
  • The Broken Soldier
  • The Existentialist Cowboy
  • The Hill
  • The Reaction
  • Vagabond Scholar
  • The Zoo
  • Vote Vets-Vet Voice Blog
  • Washington Monthly
  • Watching Those We Choose
  • Welcome back to Pottersville
  • WTF Is it Now?
  • Zaius Nation
  • Zandar versus the Stupid
  • 6 Generations
  • Twitter

    Follow @BGinKC
    on Twitter

    Most Recent Tweets

    Blue Girl also blogs at:
    The Blog of the
    Jackson County
    Democratic Committee


    Click on Harry to go there!
    Powered by: SoapBlox